A Mother’s Day Phone Call Went Unanswered in 2000—26 Years Later, DNA Evidence Has Revived a Double-M*rder Investigation

At 7:55 on the morning of May 11, 2000, a telephone rang inside a modest cottage in Carrington, a harborside suburb of Newcastle, Australia.

The call came from a public pay phone only about 200 metres away. Inside the cottage were two women: 32-year-old Susan Kay and her 37-year-old friend, Joanne Teterin.

Six days later, police entered the property and discovered that both women had been murdered.

For years, the killings remained one of the region’s unresolved cold cases. Investigators interviewed witnesses, examined evidence and pursued possible leads, but no one was charged.

Then, more than two decades later, advances in DNA testing and forensic technology gave detectives a new reason to revisit the investigation.

Police say more than 150 exhibits have been retested. Some results have produced significant information, and detectives believe one particular detail could be crucial: the telephone call made shortly before the women were killed.

A $1 million reward is now being offered for information that helps solve the murders.

But behind the renewed investigation is an especially painful story. Three days after that mysterious call, a nine-year-old girl tried to reach her mother on Mother’s Day.

This time, nobody answered.

The Two Women at the Centre of the Carrington Murders

Susan Kay was 32 and the mother of a young daughter, Samantha, who was just nine years old when her life changed forever.

On the morning of Thursday, May 11, 2000, Susan went grocery shopping before driving to the home of her friend Joanne Teterin.

Joanne lived in a miner’s cottage on Doran Street in Carrington. Although relatively little has been made public about her personal life, investigators later established that drugs were being sold from the property.

Police also learned about a strict arrangement governing visitors.

Anyone wanting to buy drugs from the house was expected to contact Joanne first, either by landline or mobile phone. According to reports, this rule was intended to prevent unexpected visitors from arriving at the door.

That detail would eventually become one of the most important elements of the double-murder investigation.

Susan’s family remembers her as a fiercely loyal woman who cared deeply about the people closest to her.

Her sister, Desiree, has described Susan as someone who could always find a little mischief but was also protective and devoted to her family.

She was not perfect, her sister acknowledged, but neither was anyone else.

To those who loved her, Susan was far more than the woman whose name appeared in a police investigation. She was a mother, daughter, sister and aunt whose absence would be felt for generations.

Joanne, meanwhile, was 37 and lived at the cottage where the two women were eventually found.

The circumstances surrounding her final hours remain central to the questions detectives are still trying to answer.

The 7:55 A.M. Telephone Call That Became a Critical Clue

At approximately 7:55 a.m. on May 11, a telephone rang inside the Doran Street cottage.

According to police, the call originated from a nearby public telephone.

The distance between the pay phone and Joanne’s home was only about 200 metres.

Why was that call made?

Investigators believe the answer may be connected to Joanne’s rule that customers had to telephone before visiting the property.

Detective Superintendent Joe Douihy has explained that police believe the caller was known to Joanne and that the call may have been made to arrange a visit.

It is an important distinction: detectives have described this as an investigative theory based on the evidence available to them, not a proven account of everything that happened.

Nevertheless, the call has remained an important part of the case.

Police believe a man may have visited the cottage to buy drugs, that an altercation may have followed, and that the incident resulted in the deaths of both women.

Investigators also believe the person who made the call could hold information that would help them establish what happened.

But the identity of the caller has not been publicly established, and police have not announced that anyone has been charged in connection with the murders.

Mother’s Day: The Phone Call a Nine-Year-Old Girl Never Forgot

Just three days after the mysterious morning call, Sunday, May 14, 2000, arrived.

It was Mother’s Day in Australia.

For Samantha, it should have been an ordinary opportunity to speak with her mother. Susan was someone who normally answered her daughter's calls.

But that Sunday, the telephone rang without an answer.

Samantha had no way of knowing that her mother was already dead.

On Wednesday, May 17, shortly before midday, police forced their way into the cottage. Inside, they discovered Susan and Joanne.

Both women had suffered fatal blunt-force injuries. Investigators described the killings as brutal and violent.

By then, six days had passed since the women were last known to be alive.

Samantha’s father was left with the devastating responsibility of telling his nine-year-old daughter that her mother would never come home.

Years later, Samantha described the moment in a letter shared with The Daily Telegraph.

She wrote that her world shattered immediately. At first, she struggled to accept what had happened, waking the following morning believing the news might have been a terrible dream.

When reality returned, the grief hit her all over again.

She explained that the pain continued day after day, becoming part of her life for as long as she could remember.

For Samantha, the unanswered Mother’s Day call became more than a detail in a police timeline. It represented the beginning of a lifetime of milestones her mother would never witness.

An Investigation That Failed to Produce an Arrest

Following the discovery, Newcastle police launched an investigation with assistance from specialist homicide and serious-crime detectives.

Investigators quickly established that drugs had been sold from Joanne’s home. They came to believe that the killings could have been connected to that activity.

Detectives interviewed people who had visited the cottage and examined the movements of individuals who may have had contact with the women.

Police also appealed for information from anyone who had been at a nearby shopping centre during the hours leading up to the suspected killings.

Carrington itself was a distinctive location.

The harbourside suburb had a relatively small population and was geographically separated from neighbouring areas by Throsby Creek. The Cowper Street Bridge provided a major route into the community.

The surrounding industrial landscape was also changing.

In September 1999, BHP closed the Newcastle Steelworks, a major industrial site that had employed thousands of people during its history. Demolition began in 2000, the same year Susan and Joanne were murdered.

These details formed part of the wider setting in which detectives were trying to reconstruct the women’s final movements.

But despite interviews, public appeals and investigative work, no arrest followed.

The case remained unresolved.

The 2003 Coronial Inquest and the First Major Reward

In June 2003, approximately three years after the murders, a coronial inquest began examining the circumstances surrounding the deaths.

At the time, police had identified several people of interest, although no one had been charged.

A $100,000 reward was announced in the hope that someone with relevant information would finally come forward.

Detective Sergeant Kel Platt said investigators hoped the financial incentive would encourage people to share what they knew.

Police were particularly interested in information that might previously have seemed unimportant or too uncertain to report.

The coroner ultimately found that Susan and Joanne had been murdered by an unknown person.

The case was subsequently referred to the homicide squad’s unsolved-homicide investigators for further assessment.

For the families, however, the inquest did not provide the answers they desperately needed.

The identity of the killer remained unknown, and Samantha continued growing up without her mother.

Why Advances in Forensic Science Changed the Investigation

One of the biggest developments in the case came years after the original investigation.

Modern DNA analysis has transformed the way detectives approach older criminal investigations. Biological material that once produced limited or inconclusive results may now provide useful information through improved laboratory techniques.

This does not mean every old exhibit can produce a DNA profile or identify a suspect. Results depend on the condition of the material, the amount of biological evidence available and whether a usable comparison can be made.

However, even a small amount of previously unhelpful evidence can sometimes become more valuable when examined using newer methods.

The broader issue of how police handle unresolved killings in New South Wales also received renewed attention.

In 2023, a special commission of inquiry led by Justice John Sackar examined suspected hate crimes against LGBTQ people and also considered the handling of cold cases by New South Wales police.

The inquiry was not specifically about the Carrington murders. However, its findings raised concerns about the speed and consistency of cold-case reviews.

Its extensive final report called for a broader audit of unsolved homicides and for police to identify evidence that should be submitted or resubmitted for forensic examination.

In September 2024, the state government announced support for all 19 of the inquiry’s public recommendations.

A working group was established to help plan the audit and determine which exhibits might benefit from further laboratory testing.

The Carrington murders fell within the period covered by the wider review.

Although no direct public connection has been established between that audit and the renewed investigation, the broader push for forensic reassessment reflected a changing approach to unsolved cases.

For Susan and Joanne’s families, the possibility that old evidence could reveal something new offered a reason to hope.

Strike Force Rafo II Reopens the 25-Year-Old Case

In 2025, as the 25th anniversary of the murders approached, the New South Wales Police Unsolved Homicide Unit established a dedicated investigation known as Strike Force Rafo II.

Detectives were assigned to revisit the original evidence, review previous investigative decisions, interview witnesses again and pursue new lines of inquiry.

The aim was to determine whether developments in forensic science could provide answers that had remained beyond reach in 2000.

Detective Superintendent Joe Douihy described the killings as a brutal crime that had remained unsolved for 25 years.

He said homicide investigators remained committed to securing justice for both families and urged anyone with information to come forward, even if they believed their knowledge was minor.

The investigation was no longer limited to what detectives could establish using the methods available a quarter of a century earlier.

This time, the original exhibits were being examined with the benefit of modern forensic capabilities.

And the results, police said, were significant.

More Than 150 Exhibits Retested as DNA Evidence Produces New Information

One of the most important public updates came when Douihy revealed that investigators had arranged for more than 150 exhibits to be retested.

Some of the results, he said, were positive and had helped progress the investigation.

He also indicated that the forensic work had produced significant information that detectives did not have when the murders first occurred.

Police have not publicly disclosed exactly which exhibits produced useful results, what biological material was examined or whether a particular DNA profile has been identified.

The laboratory involved and the precise testing methods have also not been publicly detailed.

That means it would be premature to claim that DNA has identified the killer.

What police have confirmed is that advances in forensic DNA technology have provided new investigative opportunities and helped explain why the case was receiving renewed attention.

Strike Force Rafo II detectives have also been working throughout Newcastle and surrounding suburbs, speaking with witnesses and following up information.

The investigation has therefore involved more than laboratory testing. It has combined a fresh examination of physical evidence with renewed efforts to reconstruct the events surrounding the murders.

For families who have waited decades, even the confirmation that significant new information has emerged represents a major development.

The Reward Rises to $1 Million in a Fresh Police Appeal

On May 25, 2026, New South Wales police made another major public appeal.

The reward for information leading to the resolution of the murders was increased from $100,000 to $1 million.

The higher amount reflected the state's reward framework, which allows substantial rewards for information relating to serious crimes, including homicide.

Samantha attended the announcement alongside her aunt Desiree and members of Joanne’s family.

The event brought the investigation back into public attention and gave the families an opportunity to speak directly about the impact of the murders.

Samantha said her mother had been brutally taken from the family on Mother’s Day 2000.

After years of grief and unanswered questions, she said the person responsible remained free.

Somewhere, she believes, someone knows what happened to Susan.

Her request was simple: she wanted the truth, justice for her mother and the chance for her family to find some peace.

Police Minister Yasmin Catley also stressed that investigators do not simply abandon cases because time has passed.

She said detectives had continued following leads and revisiting evidence, and that the increased reward was intended to remind the public that the investigation remained active.

Even a conversation someone remembered, a sighting they had dismissed or a detail they had never considered important could potentially help.

Why Detectives Keep Returning to the 7:55 A.M. Call

Despite the new forensic work, the telephone call remains one of the most significant publicly discussed aspects of the investigation.

According to Douihy, anyone visiting Joanne’s property to purchase drugs was expected to telephone first.

Police believe the 7:55 a.m. call may have been made for that purpose.

Their current theory is that the caller was known to Joanne and that a man subsequently attended the cottage.

Detectives believe an altercation may have taken place, leading to the deaths of both women.

They also believe the person who made the call may be able to assist the investigation.

However, police have not publicly established the caller’s identity, and the theory should not be confused with a finding of guilt.

No individual has been publicly charged over the murders.

The distinction matters because a person who made a telephone call, visited the cottage or had contact with either woman is not automatically responsible for what happened.

Investigators are seeking information that can be tested against the available evidence.

The central question remains remarkably simple: who made that call, and what happened after it was answered?

A Daughter Who Has Spent 26 Years Waiting for Answers

For Samantha, the passage of time has not removed the loss.

She has grown from a nine-year-old girl into an adult, but her mother was absent from every birthday, important achievement and difficult moment that followed.

She has had to build a life around a loss that began with a telephone call that went unanswered.

Desiree has also spoken about the continuing effect on the family.

Nothing can bring Susan back or restore the years that were taken from them. But finding out what happened, she believes, would make a difference.

Susan left a large hole in the family, and her sister has made clear that she does not want the person responsible to escape accountability.

She also wants people to remember Susan as a real person rather than simply a name attached to an unsolved murder.

Susan was a mother, daughter, sister and aunt. She had a family that loved her and relatives she never had the chance to meet.

Her memory has remained part of their lives, even as the investigation continued for more than two decades.

Joanne’s loved ones have also waited for answers about the woman whose home became the scene of the killings.

Both families deserve to know what happened.

Police Say the Carrington Murders Are Still Solvable

Detective Superintendent Douihy has urged anyone who had dealings with Susan or Joanne around the time of the murders to reconsider whether they might hold information that could help.

He believes the passage of time may encourage someone who previously remained silent to speak with investigators.

During the 2026 appeal, he described the matter as solvable and said detectives needed additional information to complete the investigation.

The $1 million reward is intended to encourage that final piece of information to emerge.

Police are particularly interested in anyone who remembers the circumstances surrounding the cottage, the nearby public telephone or the people who may have visited the property on May 11, 2000.

A person may have overheard something, noticed an unusual movement or learned information that seemed insignificant at the time.

More than 26 years later, that detail could have a different meaning.

Anyone with information can contact Crime Stoppers on 1800 333 000. Police have asked people to provide information through the appropriate reporting channels rather than sending tips through social media pages.

As of November 2026, public reporting indicates that no one has been charged in connection with the deaths of Susan Kay and Joanne Teterin.

The investigation remains unresolved.

The Question That Has Followed This Family for 26 Years

The story of the Carrington murders is not simply about an old crime scene or a collection of exhibits waiting to be examined.

It is about two women whose lives ended violently, two families left searching for answers and a little girl who called her mother on Mother’s Day and heard only the telephone ringing.

The renewed investigation has brought new attention to the case. More than 150 exhibits have been retested, police have reported significant forensic developments, and the reward has reached $1 million.

Yet the most important question remains unanswered.

Who made the 7:55 a.m. telephone call?

Police believe that person may hold information capable of moving the investigation forward. Whether the answer comes from a new witness, a forgotten conversation or further forensic analysis, detectives are still seeking the evidence needed to establish what happened.

For Samantha, the hope is not complicated.

She wants to know who took her mother away, why it happened and whether the truth can finally be established.

A quarter of a century has passed since that Mother’s Day telephone call went unanswered.

But for the families of Susan Kay and Joanne Teterin, the search for answers has never ended.

The person who knows what happened may still be out there. And investigators are asking them to come forward.

Disclaimer: This article is based on publicly reported information and police statements. The account of the 7:55 a.m. call and the events that may have followed reflects an investigative theory, not a proven finding. No person has been charged or found guilty in connection with these deaths.

0/Post a Comment/Comments

Previous Post Next Post