A legal campaign involving King Charles III has taken
an international turn after an Australian court rejected an Indigenous elder’s
latest attempt to pursue a private prosecution against the monarch.
The case, brought by Krautatungalung elder and
activist Robbie Thorpe, has been unfolding through Australian courts since
2023. Thorpe alleges that the King, together with Australian government
institutions, is responsible for continuing systems that disadvantage
Indigenous Australians and that those circumstances amount to genocide.
Those allegations have not been established by a court.
On September 28, three judges of Victoria’s Court of
Appeal rejected Thorpe’s latest attempt to advance the proposed prosecution.
The decision marked another setback in his effort to bring the case before an
Australian criminal court.
But the ruling did not end the story.
Thorpe has said he intends to continue pursuing the
allegations, including by seeking to bring them to the attention of the International Criminal Court (ICC)
after exhausting available avenues in Australia.
That raises a much larger legal question: what
happens when an individual attempts to move a domestic private prosecution into
the international criminal justice system?
Why King Charles became the focus
of the case
King Charles occupies a distinctive constitutional
position in Australia.
Although he is the monarch of the United Kingdom, he
is also formally the King
of Australia, meaning the Australian constitutional system
recognizes him as the country's head of state.
Thorpe's case argues that the Crown and Australian
institutions have continuing responsibility for conditions affecting Indigenous
Australians.
According to ABC News and the Associated Press, the
allegations concern socioeconomic disadvantages experienced by Indigenous
people, including disparities involving health, life expectancy, unemployment
and imprisonment. Indigenous Australians account for roughly 4 percent of
Australia's population, according to the reports.
Thorpe argues that these conditions should be
considered in the context of genocide.
Australian courts, however, have not accepted the
proposed prosecution as a legally valid proceeding.
That distinction is central to understanding what has
happened.
The court did not rule that the
allegations were proven
The latest judgment was not a trial determining
whether genocide had occurred.
Instead, the Court of Appeal considered whether
Thorpe could proceed with the legal mechanism he had attempted to use.
The court rejected his application to appeal, agreeing
with the earlier judicial conclusion that the proposed charges did not disclose
an offence known to Victorian law.
ABC reported that the judges acknowledged the
significance of the questions raised by Thorpe but concluded that the lower
court had acted within its jurisdiction.
The decision therefore represents a procedural and
jurisdictional barrier rather than a criminal trial verdict on the underlying
historical and political allegations.
That distinction is particularly important because
the word genocide
carries a specific meaning under international law and is not simply another
term for discrimination, historical injustice or government policy.
Thorpe has one more Australian
legal avenue
The Court of Appeal ruling was described as Thorpe's
third legal defeat since he began trying to initiate the private prosecution in
2023.
However, his domestic options have not necessarily
been completely exhausted.
He can seek permission to appeal to the High Court of Australia,
although the Associated Press reported that the High Court accepts only a
relatively small proportion of applications for leave to appeal.
Whether such an application proceeds is therefore a
separate question from whether Thorpe ultimately succeeds in bringing criminal
charges against the King.
For now, the Court of Appeal decision prevents the
proposed prosecution from moving forward through the path Thorpe has pursued.
Why the International Criminal
Court changes the legal question
Thorpe has said he intends to take his allegations to
the International
Criminal Court in The Hague after completing the available
Australian processes.
That statement has attracted international attention
because the ICC operates under a fundamentally different legal framework from
an Australian state court.
But there is an important limitation.
An individual cannot simply file a private criminal
prosecution at the ICC in the same way a person may attempt to initiate certain
proceedings in a domestic legal system.
International law expert Don Rothwell of the Australian
National University explained to the Associated Press that an individual can
instead provide information or evidence to the ICC prosecutor.
The prosecutor then determines whether the
information warrants further consideration under the court's jurisdiction.
In other words, Thorpe's proposed international step
would not automatically create an ICC prosecution against King Charles.
The difference between submitting
evidence and starting a case
This distinction could become one of the most
important parts of the next stage.
Thorpe has described his Australian legal proceedings
as part of a broader effort to establish what he believes are serious
violations against Indigenous Australians.
If he approaches the ICC, however, the process would
be controlled by the court's own legal framework.
The ICC prosecutor would have to consider whether the
allegations fall within the court's jurisdiction and whether the available
evidence satisfies the applicable legal requirements.
An individual therefore cannot decide independently
that a particular person will be prosecuted at The Hague.
That decision belongs to the international criminal
justice process.
What about immunity for King
Charles?
Another complicated issue is sovereign immunity.
Legal experts cited by the Associated Press said the
British monarch has extensive common-law immunity from criminal and civil
liability in the United Kingdom.
Sydney University constitutional law professor Anne
Twomey told the AP that this protection is likely to have been inherited by
Australia, although she said she was unaware of the question having previously
been tested in an Australian court.
The issue becomes more complicated when international
criminal law enters the discussion.
The ICC does not treat head-of-state status as an
automatic bar to its jurisdiction in the same way that domestic immunity can
operate.
But that does not mean every allegation against a
sitting head of state automatically becomes an ICC case.
Jurisdiction, admissibility, evidence and the
requirements of the Rome Statute would still have to be considered.
A legal campaign that began in
Melbourne
Thorpe's effort dates back to 2023, when he attempted
to commence a private prosecution against King Charles in the Melbourne
Magistrates' Court.
His proposed charges alleged continuing acts of
genocide against First Peoples.
The Magistrates' Court did not issue the proposed
proceedings.
Thorpe subsequently challenged that decision in the
Victorian Supreme Court before taking the matter to the Court of Appeal.
The Supreme Court previously concluded that the
proposed charge-sheet did not disclose an offence capable of engaging the
relevant criminal jurisdiction.
The latest Court of Appeal decision has now added
another layer to that legal history.
The broader Indigenous rights
debate
The case exists within Australia's much larger debate
over the treatment, rights and constitutional status of Aboriginal and Torres
Strait Islander peoples.
There are significant disparities between Indigenous
and non-Indigenous Australians in areas including health, life expectancy,
imprisonment and employment.
Those disparities are documented by Australian
authorities and have been the subject of decades of public policy debate.
Thorpe's legal argument goes substantially further,
alleging that the continuing effects of government systems amount to genocide.
That interpretation is his allegation and has not
been established by an Australian court.
The distinction matters because the legal definition
of genocide requires specific elements and intent under international law.
Why the case has attracted
international attention
The involvement of a reigning monarch gives the case
an unusual constitutional dimension.
King Charles is simultaneously the British monarch
and Australia's head of state.
That means a legal dispute originating in Melbourne
has implications involving Australian
constitutional law, the British Crown, Indigenous rights and international
criminal law.
The case also raises broader questions about whether
individuals can use private prosecutions to challenge alleged wrongdoing by
governments and constitutional institutions.
Australian courts have now placed significant limits
on Thorpe's attempt to use that route.
The proposed move toward the ICC represents a
different legal strategy.
What happens next?
For the moment, there are several possible stages to
watch.
Thorpe may seek permission to appeal to Australia's
High Court.
If his domestic legal avenues are exhausted, he has
indicated that he intends to provide his allegations to the International
Criminal Court.
But even that step would not guarantee an
investigation or prosecution.
As Rothwell explained to the Associated Press, an
individual can bring information to the attention of the ICC prosecutor, but
the prosecutor decides whether the circumstances justify further action.
That means the next chapter could be considerably
different from the Australian proceedings that have taken place since 2023.
A case now moving beyond
Australia's courts
The Court of Appeal's decision has closed another
route for Thorpe's proposed private prosecution, but it has not ended his
campaign.
His stated intention to pursue the allegations
internationally means the dispute could continue to attract attention far
beyond Victoria.
For King Charles, the case also highlights the
unusual constitutional position he occupies in Australia and the complicated
relationship between monarchy,
sovereign immunity and international criminal law.
For Indigenous Australians, the case sits within a
much broader and long-running discussion about historical injustice,
contemporary inequality and recognition of Indigenous rights.
And for international law observers, the most
important question may now be less about whether an individual can personally
prosecute a monarch and more about what happens when allegations that have
failed to advance through domestic courts are presented to an international
prosecutor.
For now, no ICC prosecution against King Charles has been initiated by Thorpe. The Australian court proceedings have reached another legal barrier, while any possible international step remains subject to the ICC's own procedures and decisions.

Post a Comment